Car shipping fraud tends to follow a few patterns. Money gets collected before any truck exists, a price climbs once the car is out of your hands, or someone borrows the name and numbers of a real company. Each pattern leaves a sign you can check before you pay, and most of the checks take a phone call or a free FMCSA lookup.
Money requested before a carrier is assigned
A shipping company has nothing to send you until a carrier agrees to haul your car. A request for a large deposit on the day you book, before any carrier is named, puts your money at risk with nothing in return yet. If the company then stops answering, you have no truck and no easy way to get the money back.
Ask which carrier the payment is for and what its MC number is. If there is no answer, wait. Broadway asks for $0 until a carrier is dispatched to your car, and the balance goes to the driver at delivery.
Unusual payment methods and changed account details
With Broadway, our part is charged to a card and the driver takes cash or certified funds at delivery. Requests to pay with gift cards, cryptocurrency or a wire to an individual's account are warning signs on their own.
A subtler version arrives after you have booked with a real company. An email or text that looks like it comes from your broker says the payment details have changed and gives a new account. Our shipping agreement says payments go only to Broadway's authorized accounts and asks customers to confirm payment details with us before paying. Do that with any company. Call the number on its website or its FMCSA record, never the number in the message. Ours is (917) 594-5566.
Know the number before you plan around it
Route-exact price in about 30 seconds. No payment details, locked 14 days.
A price far below everyone else's
A bait quote wins the booking and then fails in one of three ways. The car sits unassigned because no carrier will take it at that price. Or the price goes up a day or two before pickup, when you have run out of time to look elsewhere. Or, the worst case, someone demands more money at delivery while your car is still on the trailer.
You can test a quote before you accept it. Our state car shipping guides publish what lanes ran each month for a running sedan on an open carrier. A quote far below that figure deserves a direct question about what happens if no carrier accepts it. Prices that change for legitimate reasons, such as a non-running car or a lifted truck, should be named on the quote, and our list of charges that appear after booking shows which ones to ask about.
Names and numbers that do not match
A fake company can put a real MC number on its website. The check is to look the number up on FMCSA's SAFER Company Snapshot and compare the legal name on the record with the company you are dealing with. A different name, an inactive status, or no broker or carrier authority means you should stop.
Do the same with the carrier once it is assigned. Ask for its name and MC number before pickup, look them up, and compare them with the truck that arrives. Commercial trucks have to show the company name and USDOT number on both sides. If the truck says something different from your paperwork, call the broker before the car is loaded. Our guide on choosing a car transport company walks through the full FMCSA check, including the $75,000 bond every broker has to keep on file.
Pressure over paperwork
The Bill of Lading records the car's condition at pickup and again at delivery. It is the evidence behind any damage claim. Two tactics turn it against you.
The first is asking you to sign a blank or half-filled form at pickup, with the condition notes to be added later. Do not sign until every existing scratch and dent is written down, and take your own dated photos of every panel.
The second is rushing you at delivery. Under our agreement, damage not noted before the driver leaves is treated as waived. Walk around the car in good light, compare it with your pickup photos, and write down anything new before you sign.
Promises nobody can make
Be careful with a guaranteed pickup date offered at no cost, or a promise that every possible loss is covered. A broker does not drive the truck, and weather and road closures move schedules for everyone. Broadway's agreement does not promise exact pickup or delivery dates. Instead, the driver calls about 24 hours ahead, a coordinator texts the pickup window the day before, and there is an expedited option with a 24 to 48 hour carrier commitment on major corridors, where the fee is waived if we miss it. A company that promises more than that should be able to show you where it is in writing.
Where to check and where to report
- Company registration and authority: SAFER Company Snapshot
- Broker bond and carrier insurance filings: FMCSA's Licensing and Insurance system
- Complaints about a broker or carrier: FMCSA's National Consumer Complaint Database, or 1-888-368-7238 on weekdays
You can check us on the same sites with MC-1496533 or USDOT 3990000. When the numbers line up, get a quote for your route and see every line before anything is due.
